What is the best butter pecan ice cream?

KUSA - Consumer Reports went shopping for the best butter pecan ice cream, and the winner was Haagen-Dazs - but not by a wide margin.

The Haagen-Dazs was pricey, at $3.91 for just 14-ounces. While it was terrific tasting, it is loaded with fat and calories. One serving has 300 calories, 22 grams of fat and 17 grams of sugar.

A very close second was the least expensive ice cream in the test: the Great Value Butter Pecan from Walmart. The 1.5-quart container was $2.77 and rated very high on the "yum" scale.

Testers said it was very flavorful. It's only fault is that it was a little bit icy. It also had almost half the fat and calories of the Haagen-Dazs, with only 160 calories per serving, 10 grams of fat and 33 grams of sugar.

Blue Bunny was third at $3.50 for a 1.75 quart container. It was hurt in the competition because testers say while it had great vanilla and custard notes, it was sparse on nuts. It comes in at 150-calories per serving, with 9 grams of fat and 13 grams of sugar.

The last place finisher was Turkey Hill Butter Pecan. It sells for $3.99 for a 1.5 quart container. Turkey Hill has wonderful butterscotch notes with a touch of vanilla, salt and custard. However, it lost points for its pecans, which were a little bitter, and has a slightly icy texture as well.

Kroger's ice creams drew honorable mention for both price and quality, but generally could not compete with the big name brands in this category.


To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the
Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Leave a Comment