Charles Buckland was driving for PNR Services out of Dolores when was arrested Monday on suspicion of motor-vehicle theft and reckless driving.
Police say Buckland repossessed the wrong vehicle, prompting the owner to call two friends who gave chase.
During the chase, Buckland hit another vehicle, leading that driver to join the pursuit.
Two of the three pursuers were cited for reckless driving.
According to the Durango Herald, authorities discovered there was a similar vehicle down the street, each with a license plate that begins with 433.
Only the three letters differed.
(Copyright 2012 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)