Breaking News
More () »

Man sent cellphone to Aurora girl a week before she disappeared, affidavit says

Navarro Cathey, 41, was arrested in Utah, where the missing Aurora girl was found under blankets in the back of his car, an affidavit says.

AURORA, Colo. — A week before a 13-year-old Aurora girl was taken across state lines by a California man, that man sent her a cellphone with a note that said "my baby girl" and from "your daddy", according to an affidavit for his arrest from the Aurora Police Department (APD).

Navarro Cathey, 41, was arrested in Utah a day after the girl was reported missing and faces the following charges:

  • Sexual exploitation of a child
  • Internet luring of a child
  • Internet exploitation of a child

The girl was reported missing Nov. 23 from her Aurora home by her mother, who said she was last seen about 2 p.m., Aurora Police said.

A week prior, on Nov. 16, the girl's mother confronted her about a package she received that contained a cellphone, that affidavit says. That resulted in a fight between them and her mother eventually contacting police, the affidavit says.

The mom reported to police that her daughter had received a cellphone from an "unknown person" whom she had been talking to over the internet, the affidavit says.

The girl's mom said she would give police information about her daughter's social media accounts and emails, as well as information about the Amazon package sent to her daughter, according to the affidavit.

RELATED: AMBER Alert deactivated after Aurora girl found safe; suspect arrested

On Nov. 23, the girl's mom notified police that her daughter was missing. At that time, detectives were provided with a string of emails between the girl and the suspect, who identified himself as Nathaniel McKinley in the emails and said he was 28.

According to the affidavit, the conversations "quickly" became sexual in nature, and the man arranged to meet the girl, who said in the email exchanges that she was 13.

Credit: Aurora Police Department
Photo of Navarro Cathey and a stock photo of a 2001 Dark Blue Ford Crown Victoria with tinted windows and spotlight on driver side.

Investigators reached out to Amazon about the package that was sent to the girl and determined which account purchased the phone, the affidavit says. That led them to Cathey, whose middle name is Nathaniel. From there, detectives found a vehicle registered to him and learned that a Vail police officer had run the plate for it about 7:30 a.m. Nov. 24.

Once an AMBER Alert was issued for the girl, detectives received tips that a vehicle matching that description was seen leaving the neighborhood where the girl lives, the affidavit says.

Officers responded to the tipper's home and were able to find a video of the car driving in the area and then parking near the girl's home, the affidavit says. A short time later, a female was seen in the video exiting the home and getting into the vehicle, according to the affidavit.

RELATED: Parenting expert weighs in on abductions stemming from meeting online

The approximate time stamp on the video roughly matched the time when the girl's mother noticed her daughter was missing from the backyard, the affidavit says.

An emergency ping was done on Cathey's cellphone, which showed him to be in Utah, which is where he was eventually arrested, according to the affidavit. Several tips also came in from people who reported that they had seen the vehicle earlier in the day on Interstate 70.

About 4:40 p.m. Nov. 24, Aurora Police were notified by the Utah Highway Patrol (UHP) that they had stopped the vehicle and that Cathey was in custody. UHP said the girl was safe and had been found under some blankets in the back seat of the car, the affidavit says.

Cathey is currently in custody in Sevier County, Utah, where he's facing drug charges, according to APD.

SUGGESTED VIDEOS: Investigations from 9Wants to Know 

Paid Advertisement