Denver's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Denver, Colorado | 9NEWS.com

Proposed fee could help remove space junk in Earth's crowded lower orbit

Earth's lower orbit is the only part of space currently inhabited by humans, and there are an estimated 20,000 bits of space junk in its orbit.

BOULDER, Colo. — Space is big, but that doesn't mean it can't get overcrowded.

A launch by SpaceX Wednesday brought 60 new Starlink satellites to space. Those are the spacecraft clusters that are designed to cover the planet with broadband internet.

There is now a total of 482 Starlink satellites in orbit, and SpaceX hopes to launch at least 800 more. 

Those will join the other 2000 satellites already cruising around in a part of space called lower earth orbit (LEO), which is about 150 to 2000 kilometres (roughly 93 to 1242 miles) above the earth, just above the atmosphere. 

That zone is also the only part of space currently inhabited by humans, and has an estimated 20,000 bits of space junk; old dead satellites, pieces that break off of satellites, along with pieces of rockets that pass through or deliver satellites to LEO. 

RELATED: Campus is closed so students are building a communications satellite from home

“The thing to keep in mind, is that in order to maintain orbit there, objects have to travel at very high rates of speed," said Akhil Roa, a former PhD student in environmental economics at CU Boulder. "At tens of thousands of miles per hour, even things like paint flecks can pose really big dangers.”

He says major collisions between spacecraft have not been common, but the theory among scientists is that as lower earth orbit gets more congested, a collision will likely result in exponential damage.  

“You got some junk up there that hits some stuff, creates more junk, hits more stuff, creates more junk, and you’ve got this cycle where collisions beget collisions, said Roa. "This problem has the potential to get really nasty kind of quickly.”

He said that most satellites have a end of life plan to de-orbit and burn up in the atmosphere, but sometimes they malfunction before the end of their anticipated lifespan. That leaves them in wander, and in the way of other satellites. 

Roa said that one evolving method for cleaning up lower earth orbit is garbage collection. Physically removing space junk with nets, harpoons and even lasers, but he thinks that will no be enough.

“The reason why we think they’re not enough is because the fundamental problem here is about incentives, its about the incentive to launch in the first place, to keep the satellite up there in the first place,” he said.

Rao, who is now an assistant professor at Middlebury College, just had a research paper published this week. It was co-authored by his professor at CU Boulder, Daniel Caffine, and assistant professor Matthew Burgess.

Their idea is to implement a kind of tax called an orbital use fee on every satellite. He says that will help ensure that satellite operators factor in the potential cost if something goes wrong and their satellite.

Rao said in most cases now, satellite operators only have to consider the cost of building, launching and maintaining satellites, and not what happens to them if there is an issue.

He said the fee would be equal for all users internationally, and will raise annually as the orbital space becomes safer and safer. Their paper projected that this plan will quadruple the overall value of the satellite industry by 2040.  

“So now when you launch a satellite, you’re only going to launch it if it’s valuable enough to not only cover your cost, but the cost that you are imposing to others,” said Rao.

RELATED: New advisory program to warn airplanes about solar storms


There is success of a similar plan in the fisheries of international waters.

Rao compared their orbital use fee idea to the The Vessel Day Scheme that the nations to the Nauru Agreement use to manage a shared tuna fishery in the Pacific Ocean.  

"The amount that the vessels pay is harmonized. The island nations keep the revenues for themselves, and they spend it domestically. It's politically popular. We think an approach like that could work here," he said. 

Rao said that instead of greed, waste, and competition, all involved from the countries to the companies, are all focused on maintaining the sustainability and the health of the fishery. 


RELATED: Satellite train seen from Colorado

RELATED: NASA releases the most complete record of rain and snow data