x
Breaking News
More () »

Appeals court grants new trial after issue with jury instructions

Brandon Karr was initially arrested in 2016 after a fatal shooting in the 4500 block of Sheridan Boulevard on Aug. 7 in Adams County.

ADAMS COUNTY, Colo. — A man who was convicted in 2017 on 12 counts including second-degree murder, multiple counts of attempted murder, and assault will get a new trial a Colorado appeals court ruled last year.

Brandon Karr was initially arrested in 2016 after a shooting in the 4500 block of Sheridan Boulevard on Aug. 7 in Adams County. When deputies responded to that area early that morning they found two people dead and four others injured.

Karr and another man Rojelio Heredia were both arrested.

RELATED: Man killed in Denver house party shooting identified

On May 8, 2017, Karr was convicted on the following 12 counts and sentenced to 26 years in prison.

  • Second-degree murder - heat of passion
  • Nine counts attempted first-degree murder
  • Two counts assault

Karr was accused of firing from a vehicle into a crowd as he and a group of friends drove away after a confrontation at a mobile home park. Edgar Munoz, 30, was killed as a result, according to the Adams County coroner's office.

Investigators said Heredia had fired at the vehicle, hitting and killing Karr's cousin, 22-year-old Dustin Karr, according to an Associated Press report.

Court records show Heredia was sentenced to 10 years in prison after he pleaded guilty to a single count of second-degree murder on April 7, 2017. Other counts were dismissed.

RELATED: Adams County house where shooting happened was short-term rental, police say

Karr is currently set to go to trial in January after the appeals court set aside his initial conviction last year. According to a spokesman for the district attorney's office, the decision was based upon inadequate jury instructions related to a self-defense theory in the case.

SUGGESTED VIDEOS: Investigations & Crime  

Before You Leave, Check This Out